Statewide Assessments for Homeschoolers: What You Need to Know

Summary: Statewide assessments can feel overwhelming and may not seem relevant to your homeschool child, but understanding these tests is key to making informed decisions about them.

In this post, we break down the purpose of these tests, why they exist, and what to consider if you have the option to test or not. Whether testing is required or optional in your state, this guide will help you navigate the process with confidence.

For many homeschooling parents, the idea of statewide assessments can feel overwhelming or confusing. Why are they necessary? Do they really matter for your homeschooler? And, most importantly, how do you navigate these tests while ensuring they align with your homeschooling approach?

If you’ve found yourself asking these questions, you’re not alone. Understanding statewide assessments is key to making informed decisions about how you will approach them and what they mean to your homeschool program. This post will break down what you need to know about state assessments, why they exist, and how they might fit into your homeschooling journey—whether you’re just getting started or fine-tuning your approach.

Why Statewide Assessments Exist

While many will point to statewide assessments existing because of the federal No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB) or its replacement the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA), they existed in a variety of forms across states for decades beforehand. What was formalized and made consistent across all states initially by NCLB, and currently under ESSA, is that all states are required to administer standardized tests in English Language Arts (ELA) and mathematics to students in grades 3 through 8, and once during high school. Science assessments are also required once in elementary school, once in middle school, and once in high school.

Beyond the federal mandates, some states add their own requirements. For instance, some states may test students on History/Social Studies or require assessments tied to specific courses, like Biology or Civics. These additional state-level tests reflect the individual priorities or educational focus areas of that state.

While it’s important to be aware of these mandates, it’s equally important to understand how your state meets these mandates and what additional requirements are in place. The vast majority of the policies, funding, and requirements still remain the responsibility of each state. The only assessment exception is the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), which will be addressed in a future blog post.

Homeschoolers and Statewide Assessments: What’s Required?

One of the first steps for homeschooling parents is to understand the specific laws and regulations in your state. Each state has its own approach to handling statewide assessments and homeschooling, meaning the rules and regulations can differ. Additionally, the way these policies interact, whether assessments are required, optional, or can be substituted with alternative evaluations, varies from state to state. Here are some general categories that states fall into:

Required Testing: In some states, homeschoolers must participate in statewide assessments to demonstrate academic progress. This may also be a requirement for continued eligibility to homeschool.

Testing Options: Some states require some kind of testing but allow homeschoolers to use alternative assessments, such as a portfolio review or third-party evaluations to meet the requirement.

Optional Testing: Finally in other states, parents can choose whether or not their children participate in state testing. While these assessments are not mandated, there are often procedures to follow for opting out of testing.

In addition to state requirements, be sure to check for local policies and requirements that impact your homeschool program. The local level includes county, parish, service district or school district. Depending on how you’re structuring your homeschooling (as part of an umbrella school, through an independent homeschooling association, or under a district charter), there may be additional rules or guidelines at this local level. These may include deadlines, formats, testing locations or even specific accommodations for homeschoolers.

Remember, there is no hard and fast rule for statewide testing across the U.S., so it is imperative that you look into the state then local requirements to understand what to expect.

Some Benefits of Statewide Assessments for Homeschoolers

You might be wondering—if statewide assessments are not required, should I still consider them for my child? The answer largely depends on your goals and the approach you’re taking with your homeschool program. Here are a few ways these assessments might be helpful:

Being Included in Results: Participation ensures that your child is included in the academic performance data being collected and used to make decisions at the systems level, locally and across your state. Participating in these tests is like providing your voice in the data story about homeschooling in your area. Although this may seem abstract, trends in these test results are regularly considered when new legislation is debated or policies are implemented across states and local educational jurisdictions. Regular participation may contribute to very real benefits to future funding and policy decisions that may impact your child or other homeschool families.

Benchmarking Progress: Statewide assessments provide an opportunity to compare your child’s progress against other students their age, both in your area and across your state. This can help you identify some high-level strengths and areas for growth in the tested subjects.

Tracking Long-Term Trends: Over time, regular participation in statewide assessments can give you a broader picture of your child’s academic development across years, helping you make decisions. These also provide an external measure of their academic progress that may come in handy when considering future curriculum choices, enrollment options, or even college readiness.

Meeting State Requirements: In states where testing is mandatory, these assessments ensure you remain compliant with state homeschooling laws, avoiding potential legal complications down the road.

College and Career Preparation: Your child will encounter standardized tests in many different situations outside of these K-12 statewide tests. Even the written test to get a driver’s license is a standardized test! Participation in state testing can help prepare your child for future standardized test experiences, which are important for college admissions or necessary for career certifications. When it comes to a certification required by a trade to qualify for a dream job or a certain score to get into their dream college, those standardized tests will carry far higher stakes than any of these statewide tests in ELA, math, or science can every carry. Therefore there is value in using statewide tests as a learning experience in and of itself, to expose your child to the experience of a standardized test so they are more prepared when they really care about the results!

Some Drawbacks of Statewide Assessments for Homeschoolers

If you have the option not to test your child, it’s important to consider the potential drawbacks alongside the benefits. Here are a few reasons why participating in these tests might not be the best fit for your homeschool program:

Misalignment with Your Curriculum: Statewide assessments are designed to measure performance based on grade-level statewide content standards, which may not fully align with your homeschooling approach or curriculum. This is especially true if your child is working outside their tested grade level, either above or below. This mismatch could result in an inaccurate reflection of your child’s true progress.

Increased Pressure and Stress: Standardized testing environments can be stressful for students, particularly those who are not accustomed to formal exams. This pressure may detract from the more flexible, personalized learning environment that homeschooling provides. If adequate preparation isn’t possible, or if the idea of testing causes undue stress, the results may not accurately reflect your child’s academic capabilities.

Limited Scope of Assessment: Statewide tests focus only on the academic subjects of ELA, math, and science, and assess a sampling of standards for the tested grade level(s). These tests won’t capture the creative, hands-on, or interdisciplinary learning that may be central to your homeschooling program. This narrow scope may overlook important aspects of your child’s education. Understand that these results represent only one piece of information and should be considered alongside other factors to form a holistic view of your student’s progress.

What’s Next?

Statewide assessments may feel like just another hoop to jump through without any reward, but they can offer valuable external feedback about your child’s academic progress in the subjects tested. Understanding why they exist and how they apply to your homeschool plans will help you make informed choices.

Look into your state requirements and local policies and procedures as soon as possible. It is best to be prepared early so that you are fully aware of all of your options, have adequate time to prepare, thus maximizing your ability to exercise your statewide testing options with confidence.

In our next post in this series on statewide tests, we’ll explore how to prepare your child for statewide assessments to minimize stress and anxiety, ensuring they do their best. Your child deserves to feel comfortable and confident on test day. It does not have to be a stressful event. Approaching these standardized tests fully informed and feeling prepared for what to expect will also yield more reliable individual results for your child, since staying calm and focused will help them perform their best.

---

---